Overslaan en naar hoofdcontent gaan

Zoeken

ETS Professional Feature Requests

Improvements to Functions-based workflow

Opmerkingen

7 opmerkingen

U moet u aanmelden om een opmerking te plaatsen.

  • Stephen Tankard

    I agree. Functions could be a really powerful tool and a useful time saver when configuring KNX installations.
    I currently use Functions as containers to hold group addresses that relate to a particular building function. You may have discovered that it is possible to link extra group addresses to the Function. But your suggestion here would be much more useful.

    1
  • Lukáš Polívka

    You may have discovered that it is possible to link extra group addresses to the Function.

    Yep. Basically what I usually do is create a function, delete the group addresses created with it and then link my own. And then just copy functions without GAs to create more empty functions.

    Not sure if it doesn't break the functionality where ETS is able to automatically suggest/link GO-GA connections when using channel-function linking. I'll have to do more tests.

    We also need Functions for gates, garage doors, switched wall sockets, door locks etc. Later on, visualization software could use all this metadata do generate UIs easily and automatically just by importing the knxproj.

    0
  • Etienne Terblanche

    I've also posted a couple of messages, but not sure if this is just a waste of time since I'm not sure anybody is really re-acting on this?

    0
  • Michael Critchfield

    Dear Etienne, for sure not a waste of time. I read all the comments and suggestions here and keep an eye on upvotes and what users agree upon in their discussions here. It is all very valuable to us in making future versions of ETS better aligned with and overcome expectations.

    1
  • Mischel Lechte

    Michael, could you give any feedback om How this functionality is used today and in what type of projects?

    I think it's a great feature, but it seems not to have high focus from developers as the types of supported devices has not been extended much since first release.

    Can you share any plans or ideas?

    0
  • Michael Critchfield

    Dear Mischel,
    I kindly ask you to come visit me at our booth at Light + Building 2026 on March 8-13th. I’ll gladly show you and everyone else what we’re working on. Big plans and big improvements coming!

    1
  • Etienne Terblanche

    Hi Michael,

     

    Thank you for your feedback. I'm very new to KNX and ETS, but have been doing high end Home Automation for more than 25 years and started when Crestron/Lutron/AMX started. Back then it just felt like spending hours was ok, maybe because I was earning a salary instead of the business. Now I'm older and time is VERY precious for me. Thus using ETS just feels like I'm back in the 2000's. Very time consuming and "old fashion". it feels like in order to provide maximum flexibility for every product, a ton of features and settings are allowed for. However are all of it needed 90% of time?

    I did completed a large KNX home (40 odd keypads and about 200 lighting circuits, HVAC, etc.) the other day. It took me probably 10 days programming, including creating multiple scenes, etc.

    The same project will take me max 2 days and will include audio and TV zones!

    Changing and/or editing lighting scenes are a PITA in ETS.

    I see potential with using KNX, but ETS is will need to drastically setup in order to make it really worth it.

    0